A lead is not a job. A phone call, a form submission or a message is somebody saying hello. Some become booked work and some never will, and the cost of a lead tells you nothing about which kind you are paying for.
Why cost per lead can mislead
Cost per lead is easy to see, so it gets the attention. Your ad dashboard or directory listing shows it neatly. But a cheap lead that never books is more expensive than a pricier one that does. The number to watch is further down the road: what you spent on a source divided by the jobs you actually booked from it.
Four numbers and a calculator
You do not need software. You need four numbers for each source, over a stretch long enough for the jobs to close, such as a quarter.
- What you spent on that source: ad spend, directory fees, the cost of the site or the listing.
- How many leads came from it.
- How many of those became booked jobs.
- What a typical job leaves you after materials, labour and truck costs. That is margin, not the invoice total.
Divide the spend by the booked jobs to get your cost per booked job. Then set it beside the margin. If the cost is a small slice of what the job leaves you, the source is paying its way. If it eats most of the margin, something needs to change, and the fix may be in the source, the follow-up or the quote.
A made-up example
This is a made-up example with round numbers, not a real business. Suppose a trades shop tracks two sources over a quarter.
- Source A: spent 1,000 dollars, got 40 leads, booked 4 jobs. Cost per lead is 25 dollars. Cost per booked job is 250 dollars.
- Source B: spent 600 dollars, got 10 leads, booked 5 jobs. Cost per lead is 60 dollars. Cost per booked job is 120 dollars.
On cost per lead, Source A looks like the bargain. On cost per booked job, Source B is less than half the price. If a typical job leaves 1,500 dollars in margin, Source A takes about a sixth of it and Source B about a twelfth. Both are working in this example, but they are not equal, and the lead count alone would have sent the money the wrong way.
Your own numbers will differ, and the point is the method, not these figures. A handful of jobs is also a small sample, so keep a running tally. Watch a few quarters before you move money, and remember that a repeat customer or a referral can be worth more than the first job.
Ask every caller how they found you
None of this works if you do not know where the job came from. So ask every caller, every time, how they found you. Keep a notebook by the phone or a column in your job list, and write down the answer. Ask a follow-up if they say Google: was it the map, an ad or your website? Customers do not always remember, and some answers will be vague, but over a few months a pattern shows.
When a source brings plenty of leads and few jobs, the fault may not be the source. It may be what happens after the phone rings. Our post on why your leads are not converting goes through how to check that before you spend more.
A site that makes calling easy gives you more to count. See our websites for general contractors, from $250 a month plus $1,500 setup, plus tax.
Fixing what happens after the call is part of what our parent company People Purpose does in Fractional CGO.